Property Insurance

What Does Landlord Insurance Cost? Key Factors That Affect Your Premium

RightQuote Insurance
What Does Landlord Insurance Cost? Key Factors That Affect Your Premium

Landlord insurance costs more than homeowners insurance — typically 15–25% more for comparable coverage. But the range is wide, and understanding what drives the price helps you make smart decisions about coverage and cost.

Average Landlord Insurance Costs

For a single-family rental property, landlord insurance typically costs:

  • $1,000–$1,800 per year for a modest property in a lower-risk area

  • $1,500–$2,500 per year for a mid-range property in an average-risk area
  • $2,000–$3,500+ per year for a higher-value property or high-risk location

These are rough benchmarks. Your actual premium depends on the factors below.

Factors That Affect Landlord Insurance Cost

Property Location

Location is one of the most significant rating factors. Carriers look at:

  • Natural disaster risk. Properties in Colorado's hail corridor, Arizona's wildfire interface, or Minnesota's severe weather belt carry higher premiums for those specific perils.
  • Crime rates. Higher crime areas mean higher vandalism and theft risk, which increases premiums.
  • Local construction costs. Rebuilding a home in a high-cost market costs more, which means higher dwelling coverage limits and higher premiums.
  • Distance from fire station. Properties farther from fire protection pay more for fire coverage.

Property Age and Condition

Older properties typically cost more to insure because:

  • Older electrical systems (knob-and-tube, aluminum wiring) are fire risks
  • Older plumbing (galvanized steel, polybutylene) is a water damage risk
  • Older roofs are more vulnerable to wind and hail damage

A property inspection or roof certification can sometimes reduce premiums by demonstrating the property is well-maintained.

Roof Age and Type

Roof condition is one of the most heavily weighted factors in landlord insurance pricing. An older roof — especially in Colorado's hail market — can significantly increase your premium or result in ACV-only coverage.

A Class 4 impact-resistant roof can reduce your wind/hail premium by 15–30% and maintain replacement cost coverage eligibility regardless of age.

Coverage Limits and Deductibles

Higher dwelling coverage limits mean higher premiums. Higher deductibles mean lower premiums. The tradeoff is straightforward — but make sure your dwelling coverage reflects the actual replacement cost of the structure, not the market value.

A common mistake is insuring a rental property for its purchase price rather than its replacement cost. In a high-construction-cost market, these can be very different numbers.

Loss of Rental Income Coverage

The amount of loss of rental income coverage you carry affects your premium. More coverage (18–24 months vs. 12 months) costs more. But given the potential for extended repairs after a major loss, the additional premium is usually worth it.

Claims History

Your claims history — both on this property and across all properties you own — affects your premium. Multiple claims in a short period can result in significant premium increases or non-renewal.

Tenant Type

Some carriers ask about tenant type and may charge more for:

  • Section 8 / housing voucher tenants
  • Short-term rental use
  • Properties with a history of tenant turnover

Number of Units

Multi-unit properties cost more to insure than single-family rentals, but the cost per unit typically decreases as the number of units increases. A four-unit building does not cost four times as much as a single-family rental.

How to Get the Best Rate

Work with an independent broker. An independent broker can compare rates across 20+ carriers to find the best combination of coverage and price for your specific property. Carrier pricing varies significantly for the same risk.

Bundle with other policies. Some carriers offer discounts when you insure multiple properties together, or when you bundle landlord insurance with your personal homeowners and auto policies.

Invest in risk reduction. A new roof, updated electrical, security cameras, and smoke/CO detectors can all reduce your premium. Ask your agent what improvements would have the most impact.

Raise your deductible strategically. If you are financially able to absorb a higher out-of-pocket loss, a higher deductible reduces your premium. Just make sure the deductible is an amount you can actually pay.

Maintain a clean claims history. Avoid filing small claims that cost more in premium increases than the claim payout. Read our guide on when not to file a claim.

The Bottom Line

Landlord insurance is a necessary cost of owning rental property — but it does not have to be more expensive than it needs to be. Understanding what drives your premium helps you make smart decisions about coverage, deductibles, and risk reduction investments.

Talk to a RightQuote advisor about your rental property, or compare landlord insurance options across our carrier network.

Part of the Landlord Insurance Guide.

ShareFacebookLinkedInX
#landlord insurance cost#rental property insurance#landlord insurance rates#property insurance#investment property
🦉

Owl Quote You Right.

Ready to see what you should actually be paying? We compare coverage and pricing across our carrier network — free and unbiased.

Get My Free Quote